DAVID VEKSLER / CHEAT SHEETS
HARD SF · STRATEGY

Hard science fiction · strategy · 20 systems

Space combatThe possibility space.

Twenty ways to win a war, from broadsides to wars the loser never notices.

War continues policy with other means, so the unit of victory is a changed decision. Joules delivered are only one way to change it.

Chart key Shapes, colors & evidence tiers

How to read a glyph

  • Baseline human
  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Distributed swarm
  • Civilization as organism
  • Coerce
  • Disarm
  • Subvert
  • Annihilate

Shape is the combatant, color is the political aim; the side scales repeat both as labels. A dashed outline marks a secondary target row, a band spans every physics column, and a red dashed arrow means the threat reaches incentives.

Provenance: A computed here from the stated inputs (formulas in the appendix) · B checked against a listed source · C from reference knowledge, not re-verified against a source.

Physics commanded × layer targeted

Space Combat: The Possibility Space: twenty systems by physics commanded and layer targeted The plot is L-shaped. High-energy systems crowd the bottom rows; mind-targeting systems crowd the left column. The block from C2 to C4 in rows R4 and R5 is empty apart from the two bands and the two threat arrows. Nothing lives here. Nobody changes a mind with a star, except by threatening to use it. MASTERY ↖ from breaking matter to editing choices R1 Hull ships destroyed R2 Industry and logistics cannot build, fuel or move R3 Sensors and information cannot see, trust or command R4 Decision-makers leadership removed or replaced R5 Values and incentives no longer wants to fight LAYER TARGETED → C1 Chemical & EM ~10⁷ J/kg C2 Nuclear ~10¹⁴ J/kg C3 Antimatter & relativistic ~10¹⁷ J/kg C4 Stellar & gravitational a whole star: 3.8×10²⁶ W C5 Unconfirmed beyond known physics PHYSICS COMMANDED → Known physics ends here Faster-than- light travel Dimensional strikes Strange-matter conversion Monopole proton decay Triggered vacuum decay Black holes from light Nothing lives here. Nobody changes a mind with a star, except by threatening to use it. the threat is the weapon 19. Economic absorption: any × incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, undetected by the victim, aim: subvert.19Economic absorptionany × incentives · spans every physics column 20. Deterrence postures: any × incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: coerce.20Deterrence posturesany × incentives · spans every physics column 3. Laserstar: secondary target, sensors and information.3 5. Neutral particle beam: secondary target, sensors and information.5 1. Torch warship: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, months, overt, aim: coerce.1 2. Missile bus and drone carrier: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, months, overt, aim: disarm.2 3. Laserstar: nuclear × hull, also sensors. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.3 4. Bomb-pumped beams: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.4 5. Neutral particle beam: nuclear × hull, also sensors. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.5 6. Kinetic debris swarm: chemical × industry. Distributed swarm, years, deniable, aim: coerce.6 7. Crewless high-g fleet: nuclear × hull; the substrate shift. AI or uploaded crew, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.7 8. Blockade: chemical × industry. Baseline human, years, overt, aim: coerce.8 9. Redirected asteroid: nuclear × industry. Baseline human, years, overt, aim: coerce.9 10. Relativistic kill vehicle: antimatter × industry; threat reaches incentives. AI or uploaded crew, centuries, overt, aim: annihilate.10 11. Hawking black hole: gravitational × industry. Civilization as organism, years, overt, aim: coerce.11 12. Dyson-powered beam: stellar × industry; threat reaches incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: annihilate.12 13. Star manipulation: stellar × industry. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: coerce.13 14. Self-replicating swarm: chemical × industry. Distributed swarm, years, deniable, aim: annihilate.14 15. Smart dust: chemical × decision-makers. Distributed swarm, months, deniable, aim: subvert.15 16. Cyber subversion and the weaponized signal: electromagnetic × information. AI or uploaded crew, seconds, deniable, aim: subvert.16 17. Solar-lens reconnaissance: gravitational × information. AI or uploaded crew, years, undetected by the victim, aim: disarm.17 18. Persuasion engines and value editing: electromagnetic × values. AI or uploaded crew, years, undetected by the victim, aim: subvert.18 Space Combat: The Possibility Space: twenty systems by physics commanded and layer targeted The plot is L-shaped. High-energy systems crowd the bottom rows; mind-targeting systems crowd the left column. The block from C2 to C4 in rows R4 and R5 is empty apart from the two bands and the two threat arrows. Nothing lives here. Nobody changes a mind with a star, except by threatening to use it. MASTERY ↖ from breaking matter to editing choices R1 Hull R2 Industry R3 Sensors R4 Leaders R5 Values LAYER TARGETED ↑ C1 Chemical C2 Nuclear C3 Antimatter C4 Stellar C5 Unconf. PHYSICS COMMANDED → Known physics ends here Nothing lives here. Nobody changes a mind with a star, except by threatening to use it. the threat is the weapon 19. Economic absorption: any × incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, undetected by the victim, aim: subvert.19Economic absorption 20. Deterrence postures: any × incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: coerce.20Deterrence postures 3. Laserstar: secondary target, sensors and information.3 5. Neutral particle beam: secondary target, sensors and information.5 1. Torch warship: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, months, overt, aim: coerce.1 2. Missile bus and drone carrier: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, months, overt, aim: disarm.2 3. Laserstar: nuclear × hull, also sensors. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.3 4. Bomb-pumped beams: nuclear × hull. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.4 5. Neutral particle beam: nuclear × hull, also sensors. Baseline human, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.5 6. Kinetic debris swarm: chemical × industry. Distributed swarm, years, deniable, aim: coerce.6 7. Crewless high-g fleet: nuclear × hull; the substrate shift. AI or uploaded crew, seconds, overt, aim: disarm.7 8. Blockade: chemical × industry. Baseline human, years, overt, aim: coerce.8 9. Redirected asteroid: nuclear × industry. Baseline human, years, overt, aim: coerce.9 10. Relativistic kill vehicle: antimatter × industry; threat reaches incentives. AI or uploaded crew, centuries, overt, aim: annihilate.10 11. Hawking black hole: gravitational × industry. Civilization as organism, years, overt, aim: coerce.11 12. Dyson-powered beam: stellar × industry; threat reaches incentives. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: annihilate.12 13. Star manipulation: stellar × industry. Civilization as organism, centuries, overt, aim: coerce.13 14. Self-replicating swarm: chemical × industry. Distributed swarm, years, deniable, aim: annihilate.14 15. Smart dust: chemical × decision-makers. Distributed swarm, months, deniable, aim: subvert.15 16. Cyber subversion and the weaponized signal: electromagnetic × information. AI or uploaded crew, seconds, deniable, aim: subvert.16 17. Solar-lens reconnaissance: gravitational × information. AI or uploaded crew, years, undetected by the victim, aim: disarm.17 18. Persuasion engines and value editing: electromagnetic × values. AI or uploaded crew, years, undetected by the victim, aim: subvert.18

Combatant substrate

  1. Baseline human
  2. AI or uploaded crew
  3. Distributed swarm
  4. Civilization as organism

Tempo

  1. Seconds
  2. Months
  3. Years
  4. Centuries

Visibility

  1. Overt
  2. Deniable
  3. Undetected by the victim

Political aim

  1. Coerce
  2. Disarm
  3. Subvert
  4. Annihilate

What the chart shows. The plot is L-shaped. High-energy systems crowd the bottom rows; mind-targeting systems crowd the left column. The block from C2 to C4 in rows R4 and R5 is empty apart from the two bands and the two threat arrows. Nobody changes a mind with a star, except by threatening to use it.

01 · Thesis

Victory is a changed decision

Clausewitz called war "a mere continuation of policy with other means"B. The German is mit anderen Mitteln, "with", not "by": diplomacy does not stop when the shooting starts. So the unit of victory is a changed decision, and joules delivered are only one way to change it.

Three consequences organize this sheet:

  1. Energy is a poor ranking. A weapon that boils an ocean and a message that changes a vote can produce the same treaty.
  2. As a civilization masters more physics, the cheapest route to a changed decision moves up from hulls, to industry, to information, to minds.
  3. At the top, the loser may never learn there was a war.

02 · Legend

How to read the chart

Every system is placed on two main axes and four side scales.

X axis: physics commanded

ColumnRegimeEnergy densityTier
C1Chemical and electromagneticabout 1.3×107 J/kg (hydrogen and oxygen)B
C2Nuclear: fission and fusionabout 8×1013 (fission) to 3×1014 (fusion) J/kgC
C3Antimatter and relativistic9×1016 J/kg of reactantsA
C4Stellar and gravitationala whole star: 3.8×1026 WB
C5Unconfirmed physics (grayed)not applicable

A projectile at 0.9c carries 1.16×1017 J/kg of kinetic energyA, more than its own mass in antimatter fuel would release. Speed is the densest warhead known physics allows.

Y axis: layer targeted

RowTargetWhat defeat looks like
R1Hullships destroyed
R2Industry and logisticscannot build, fuel or move
R3Sensors and informationcannot see, trust or command
R4Decision-makersleadership removed or replaced
R5Values and incentivesno longer wants to fight

Side scales

  • Combatant substrate: Baseline human, aI or uploaded crew, distributed swarm, civilization as organism
  • Tempo: Seconds, months, years, centuries
  • Visibility: Overt, deniable, undetected by the victim
  • Political aim: Coerce, disarm, subvert, annihilate

03 · Constraints

Laws of the arena

  1. 01Stealth is nearly impossible.

    A room-temperature hull radiates about 460 W per square meter against a 3-kelvin skyA, and a working drive is brighter by many orders of magnitude.

  2. 02You fight the enemy's past.

    Light takes 1.3 seconds from Earth to the Moon, 8.3 minutes from the Sun to Earth and 4.2 hours from the Sun to NeptuneA.

  3. 03The rocket equation taxes everything.

    A chemical rocket needs a mass ratio of about 790 to change speed by 30 km/sA.

  4. 04Heat is the real armor problem.

    Dumping one gigawatt of waste heat at 1,000 kelvin takes about 18,000 square meters of radiatorA, and radiators cannot be armored.

  5. 05Every drive is a weapon.

    A 1,000-tonne ship holding 1 g on a fusion torch puts about 5 terawatts into its exhaustA.

  6. 06At high energy, offense wins.

    Nothing stops a relativistic impactor after launch, so deterrence replaces defense.

  7. 07Bits are cheaper than joules.

    An information attack travels at light speed, costs almost nothing to copy and leaves the prize intact.

04 · Substrate

What changes when nobody is aboard

The best-known realistic space combat assumes human crews. Remove them and most of the constraints move.

ConstraintHuman crewPost-human combatant
Accelerationa few g sustainedlimited by structure: 100 g and up
Life supportlarge share of ship massnone
Decision loopsecondsmicroseconds
Deathpermanent, politically costlya restore from backup
Patienceyearscenturies
Center of gravitybridge, capital, leadermay not exist
New attack surfacemoralecode: copy it, fork it, rewrite its goals

The last row is the important one. A mind that can be backed up can also be edited, so the decisive weapons against post-human powers sit in the top rows of the chart.

05 · Catalog

The twenty systems

Matter and energy 1 to 13

1Torch warship

nuclear × hull (C2 · R1)

  • Baseline human
  • Months
  • Overt
  • Coerce
Scale
A 1,000-tonne ship at 1 g with 1,000 km/s exhaust needs about 5 terawatts of drive power.A
Counter
Missile saturation. Its radiators are large, fragile and unarmorable.
Political use
Presence and escalation control. It can loiter, threaten and withdraw, which a missile cannot.
Fiction
The Expanse; Honor Harrington for the Age of Sail version.

2Missile bus and drone carrier

nuclear × hull (C2 · R1)

  • Baseline human
  • Months
  • Overt
  • Disarm
Scale
100 kg at a closing speed of 100 km/s hits with about 120 tons of TNT and needs no warhead.A
Counter
Point-defense lasers, counter-missiles, decoys. The fight is saturation arithmetic.
Political use
Disarmament. Cheap mass against expensive hulls.
Fiction
The Expanse.

3Laserstar

nuclear × hull, also sensors (C2 · R1 + R3)

  • Baseline human
  • Seconds
  • Overt
  • Disarm
Scale
A 10-meter mirror at 1 micron makes a 2.4 m spot at 10,000 km and a useless 73 m spot at one light-second.A
Counter
Range, ablative armor, spin, sand clouds.
Political use
Graduated force. It can blind a sensor without killing a crew.
Fiction
Children of a Dead Earth (game).C

4Bomb-pumped beams

nuclear × hull (C2 · R1)

  • Baseline human
  • Seconds
  • Overt
  • Disarm
What it is
A nuclear charge that spends itself driving a one-shot X-ray laser or a directed jet of plasma (the Casaba howitzer).
Scale
The United States ran ten known bomb-pumped X-ray laser tests between 1978 and 1988; reported efficiency was too low to be useful. Casaba was a 1960s study that grew out of Project Orion.B
Counter
It is single-use and must be pre-aimed; kill the carrier first.
Political use
Disarmament from beyond the enemy's laser range.
Fiction
The laser-head missiles of Honor Harrington.C

5Neutral particle beam

nuclear × hull, also sensors (C2 · R1 + R3)

  • Baseline human
  • Seconds
  • Overt
  • Disarm
What it is
A near-light-speed stream of neutral atoms that deposits radiation inside the target, past its armor.
Scale
A 1 MeV, 10 milliamp neutral hydrogen beam was flown to 200 km altitude in July 1989 and workedB. That is 10 kilowatts peakA; a weapon needs roughly ten thousand times more.
Counter
Mass shielding and distance. Beam spread sets the range.
Political use
A mission kill. Dead electronics, intact hull, living prisoners.
Fiction
Staple of the genre; the real one is the better story.

6Kinetic debris swarm

chemical × industry (C1 · R2)

  • Distributed swarm
  • Years
  • Deniable
  • Coerce
Scale
1 kg at 10 km/s carries about 12 kg of TNTA. A debris cascade can close an orbit for decades.C
Counter
Whipple shields, or abandoning the orbit. It denies the user too.
Political use
A poison pill for the weaker side.
Fiction
Gravity, Planetes.

7Crewless high-g fleet

nuclear × hull; the substrate shift (C2 · R1)

  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Seconds
  • Overt
  • Disarm
Scale
100 g or more, no life-support mass, microsecond decisions, expendable units.
Counter
Subversion. Light lag forces local autonomy, and autonomy makes loyalty the weak point.
Political use
Removes casualties as a brake on starting wars.
Fiction
The Culture novels.

8Blockade

chemical × industry (C1 · R2)

  • Baseline human
  • Years
  • Overt
  • Coerce
Scale
Almost no energy released. The leverage is control of fuel sources and orbital chokepoints.
Counter
Stockpiles, self-sufficiency, blockade runners.
Political use
Pure coercion, fully reversible, easy to negotiate around.
Fiction
The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress.

9Redirected asteroid

nuclear × industry (C2 · R2)

  • Baseline human
  • Years
  • Overt
  • Coerce
Scale
A 1 km rock at 20 km/s delivers about 2.7×1020 joules, roughly 65,000 megatons.A
Counter
A small nudge years ahead. The rock is visible the whole way in.
Political use
An ultimatum with a negotiating window built in.
Fiction
Footfall, The Expanse.

10Relativistic kill vehicle

antimatter × industry; threat reaches incentives (C3 · R2 → R5)

  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Centuries
  • Overt
  • Annihilate
Scale
One tonne at 0.9c carries about 28,000 megatons. Over 10 light-years it arrives about 1.1 years behind the light of its own launch.A
Counter
None after launch. Watch for the launcher, disperse, deter.
Political use
Annihilation only. Its existence creates first-strike pressure on both sides.
Fiction
The Killing Star.
Note on antimatter
1 kg meeting 1 kg of matter yields about 43 megatonsA, but only about 40 percent comes out promptly as gamma rays and much of the rest ends up in neutrinosB. Antimatter is better fuel than warhead. Its natural military use is driving things to relativistic speed.

11Hawking black hole

gravitational × industry (C4 · R2)

  • Civilization as organism
  • Years
  • Overt
  • Coerce
What it is
A black hole of about a million tonnes, smaller than a proton, radiating its mass away.
Scale
A 606,000-tonne hole is 0.9 attometers in radius. Published power estimates range from a few petawatts to 160 petawatts depending on the modelB. Its last 1,000 tonnes evaporate as about 21 million megatons.A
Making one
The classic plan, focusing light until it collapses, was argued to be impossible in a 2024 Physical Review Letters paper because the light turns into escaping particle pairs first. A 2025 reply found idealized loopholes but agreed it is implausible in practiceB. That leaves compressing matter, or finding a primordial one.
Counter
It is the loudest gamma source in the system and cannot be hidden. It also cannot easily be fed, so it runs on a clock.
Political use
Power plant, drive and time bomb in one object. Whoever holds it holds a deadline.
Fiction
David Brin's Earth.C

12Dyson-powered beam

stellar × industry; threat reaches incentives (C4 · R2 → R5)

  • Civilization as organism
  • Centuries
  • Overt
  • Annihilate
Scale
One second of the Sun's output is about 91 billion megatons. An ideal phased array 1 AU across could in principle hold a meter-scale spot at 10 light-years.A
Counter
Planets cannot dodge, but building the array takes centuries and glows in the infrared.
Political use
The ultimate deterrent. It arrives at light speed, so there is no warning at all.
Fiction
The Nicoll-Dyson beam, a concept from science fiction fandom.C

13Star manipulation

stellar × industry (C4 · R2)

  • Civilization as organism
  • Centuries
  • Overt
  • Coerce
What it is
Lifting mass off a star, provoking flares, or using a giant mirror to turn the star's own light into thrust.
Scale
A mirror thruster moves a Sun-like star about 20 m/s in the first million years.C
Counter
Time. Nothing here happens faster than a civilization can respond.
Political use
The slowest siege possible, and a demonstration of who owns the system.
Fiction
Bowl of Heaven.C

Information and mind 14 to 20

14Self-replicating swarm

chemical × industry (C1 · R2)

  • Distributed swarm
  • Years
  • Deniable
  • Annihilate
Scale
Tiny per unit, exponential in total, built from the target's own matter.
Counter
Counter-replicators, starving it of feedstock.
Political use
Poor. It cannot be recalled, so it cannot bargain.
Fiction
Berserker, Revelation Space.

15Smart dust

chemical × decision-makers (C1 · R4)

  • Distributed swarm
  • Months
  • Deniable
  • Subvert
Scale
Milligrams. Limited by power, heat and radiation, so it needs a delivery vehicle.
Counter
Airlock hygiene, immune nanotechnology, distributed leadership.
Political use
Deniable decapitation.
Fiction
The Diamond Age.

16Cyber subversion and the weaponized signal

electromagnetic × information (C1 · R3)

  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Seconds
  • Deniable
  • Subvert
Scale
A radio transmitter. It travels at light speed and costs bits.
Counter
Air gaps, never executing received code, heterogeneous systems.
Political use
Capture the fleet intact.
Fiction
A Fire Upon the Deep, A for Andromeda.

17Solar-lens reconnaissance

gravitational × information (C4 · R3)

  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Years
  • Undetected by the victim
  • Disarm
What it is
A telescope parked where a star's gravity focuses light, using the star as the lens.
Scale
The Sun's focal region starts about 548 AU out. From there a 1-meter telescope could map a planet 100 light-years away at roughly 10 km resolution.B
Counter
Almost none. It is passive, tiny and far from anything. Re-aiming it by one degree means moving about 10 AU.B
Political use
Ends hiding. An enemy that can count your shipyards from another star has already won the information war.
Fiction
None famous. This one is a funded NASA concept study.

18Persuasion engines and value editing

electromagnetic × values (C1 · R5)

  • AI or uploaded crew
  • Years
  • Undetected by the victim
  • Subvert
Scale
Negligible energy, enormous modeling compute.
Counter
Commitment devices, locked values, independent advisors. The victim cannot verify from the inside.
Political use
Victory without a treaty, because the loser agrees.
Fiction
The Player of Games.

19Economic absorption

any × incentives (C1 to C4 · R5)

  • Civilization as organism
  • Centuries
  • Undetected by the victim
  • Subvert
Scale
No weapon at all. The target is outbid for matter and energy.
Counter
Autarky, which is expensive, or merger.
Political use
Conquest that looks like trade.
Fiction
Accelerando.

20Deterrence postures

any × incentives (C1 to C4 · R5)

  • Civilization as organism
  • Centuries
  • Overt
  • Coerce
What it is
Dead-hand retaliation, hiding, or mutual hostage-holding.
Scale
Zero energy released when it works.
Counter
Decapitation, calling the bluff, exposing the hider.
Political use
The purest case of the thesis. The war is won by not occurring.
Fiction
The dark forest of The Three-Body Problem.

06 · Common mistakes

Five myths

  1. Gravity-wave weapons.

    The black hole merger detected in 2015 turned three solar masses into gravitational waves, peaking at 3.6×1049 wattsB. Standing 1 AU away, a two-meter person would be stretched by about 0.17 micronsA. Matter is almost transparent to gravitational waves, which makes them a fine signal and a hopeless weapon.

  2. Dropping a black hole on a planet.

    A million-tonne hole radiates far more than it can swallow. Even a mountain-mass hole is about the size of a protonA, so it feeds extremely slowly. A relativistic rock is cheaper.

  3. Neutrino death rays.

    They pass through the target. The one serious proposal, a 2003 paper on fizzling nuclear warheads through the planet, needed a 1,000 TeV beam from an accelerator about 1,000 km around, which its own authors called ridiculous.B

  4. Dogfights.

    There is no air to bank against and no horizon to hide behind. A crewed fighter is a missile that carries a hostage.

  5. Fireballs and shockwaves.

    There is no blast in vacuum. A nuclear weapon in space kills with X-rays, and only at short range.

07 · Out of bounds

Beyond the line: unconfirmed physics

Grayed out on the chart. Each needs physics nobody has confirmed.

  • Faster-than-light travel or signaling
  • Dimensional strikes and unfolded-proton computers (The Three-Body Problem)
  • Strange-matter conversion
  • Magnetic monopoles catalyzing proton decay
  • Triggered vacuum decay: a doomsday device that expands at light speed and takes its user with it
  • Black holes made purely from light (argued impossible in 2024, contested in 2025)B

08 · Verdict

Who actually wins?

Political aimCheapest sufficient systemWhy
CoerceBlockade (8), asteroid ultimatum (9), deterrence (20)reversible, leaves someone to sign the treaty
DisarmMissile bus (2), cyber capture (16), solar-lens reconnaissance (17)removes the means and keeps the prize
SubvertPersuasion engines (18), economic absorption (19)the loser cooperates
AnnihilateRelativistic kill vehicle (10)destroys everything worth winning

The biggest explosion is usually the most expensive way to lose the peace.

09 · Footnotes

Assumptions and arithmetic

Every figure carries a provenance tier:

  • A Computed here from the stated inputs (formulas in the appendix).
  • B Checked against a listed source.
  • C From reference knowledge, not re-verified against a source.

Constants: c = 2.998×108 m/s; 1 ton TNT = 4.184×109 J; 1 megaton = 4.184×1015 J; solar luminosity = 3.828×1026 W; 1 light-year = 9.461×1015 m; 1 AU = 1.496×1011 m; 1 Mpc = 3.086×1022 m; Stefan-Boltzmann constant = 5.670×10-8 W/m²K⁴; G = 6.674×10-11 m³/kg s².

ItemFormula and inputsResult
Torch drive power½ × thrust × exhaust velocity; 106 kg, 9.81 m/s², 106 m/s4.9×1012 W
Missile½mv²; 100 kg, 105 m/s5×1011 J = 120 tons TNT
Laser spot2.44 × wavelength × range ÷ aperture; 10-6 m, 10 m2.44 m at 107 m; 73 m at 3×108 m
Debris½mv²; 1 kg, 104 m/s5×107 J = 12 kg TNT
Asteroid1 km sphere at 2,600 kg/m³ = 1.36×1012 kg; 2×104 m/s2.7×1020 J = 65,000 Mt
Relativistic kill vehicle(γ − 1)mc²; 1,000 kg, 0.9c, γ = 2.2941.16×1020 J = 27,800 Mt
Its warning time10 ÷ 0.9 − 10 light-years1.1 years
Kinetic energy density at 0.9c(γ − 1)c²1.16×1017 J/kg
Antimatter2 kg × c²1.8×1017 J = 43 Mt
Sun, one secondluminosity ÷ megaton9.1×1010 Mt
Dyson beam spot2.44 × 10-6 m × 10 ly ÷ 1 AU, ideal optics1.5 m
Black hole radius2GM/c²; 6.06×108 kg and 1012 kg9×10-19 m; 1.5×10-15 m
Black hole final flash106 kg × c²9×1022 J = 2.1×107 Mt
Gravity-wave stretch10-21 strain × (410 Mpc ÷ 1 AU) × 2 m1.7×10-7 m
Hull glowσT⁴ at 300 K459 W/m²
Radiator area109 W ÷ σT⁴ at 1,000 K17,600 m²
Chemical mass ratioe^(30 ÷ 4.5)786
Particle beam test power1 MV × 10 mA10 kW peak
Light lagdistance ÷ c; Moon 3.844×108 m, Sun 1 AU, Neptune 30.07 AUMoon 1.28 s; Sun 8.3 min; Neptune 4.2 h

A build gate (scripts/check_space_combat.py) recomputes each row and fails if a figure on the page stops matching its rounding.

10 · Provenance

Sources

Checked 2026-11-14.

  1. Clausewitz wording and the "with" versus "by" translation issue: en.wikiquote.org, manage.thediplomat.com
  2. Black hole starship figures: Crane and Westmoreland, "Are Black Hole Starships Possible?"; summary figures; alternative power formula in Zubrin: arxiv.org, www.nextbigfuture.com, www.centauri-dreams.org
  3. Black holes from light ruled out; reply by Don Page, Physical Review Letters 135, 261402 (2025): uwaterloo.ca, journals.aps.org
  4. First gravitational-wave detection figures: arxiv.org, en.wikipedia.org
  5. Bomb-pumped X-ray laser and Casaba howitzer: en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org
  6. Neutral particle beam flight test: www.osti.gov, si.edu
  7. Solar gravitational lens: ntrs.nasa.gov, www.sci.news
  8. Antiproton annihilation products: en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org
  9. Neutrino beam proposal: Sugawara, Hagura and Sanami: arxiv.org
  10. Chemical energy density: lifeboat.com

Tier C, not re-verified against a source: fission and fusion energy densities, debris-cascade duration, the star-thruster figure, the origin of the Nicoll-Dyson name, and the fiction attributions.